History Wire

What's past is prologue.

James MarshJames Marsh

James Marsh was born in Toronto and has spent most of his working life in publishing as an editor and writer. He has edited over 200 books in Canadian history and social science and is the author of several books and over 100 articles on Canadian history.

James was editor in chief of all three print editions of The Canadian Encyclopedia (1985, 1988 and 1999) and of the Junior Encyclopedia of Canada and has continued to guide the encyclopedias into the digital world with numerous editions on CD-ROM and most recently the Online version. He is also the Director of Content Development of Historica Foundation and creator of the HistoryWire.

James is a member of the Order of Canada and recipient of the Centenary Lorne Dawson Chauveau Medal of the Royal Society of Canada in recognition of his achievement of producing The Canadian Encyclopedia.

James's interests beyond the encyclopedia range from biography, poetry and classical music to tennis (he owns several doubles and one singles title) and his puli, Sandor. For more information on James see his personal website.

Other Articles and Blog posts by James Marsh

Calixa Lavallée and the Origins of "O Canada"

March 3, 2010 11:18 PM

comments (1)

Recommend Add Comment
Canada's national anthem was first heard one fine June evening in 1880, on the campus of Laval University in Quebec City. Joseph Keaney Foran and some fellow law students were relaxing in one of the buildings when they heard a commotion at the front door. They saw Father Pierre Rouselle, the university secretary, and three other men enter the building and head straight for the piano. In the lead was a small man with a halo of black hair around his balding dome. "He was very excited," Foran later wrote of the little man, "and kept tapping his hands and saying 'I've got it! I've finally found it; I've succeeded; come, listen." He arranged himself at the piano and the others perched on a nearby dais. "Throwing back his head he played for us, for the first time, the masterpiece of his genius - it was Calixa Lavallée; he played O Canada."

"In my imagination," Foran rhapsodized, I was transported to the town of Strasbourg to the night when Rouget deLisle [sic] played and sang the Marseillaise for the first time." On June 24, 1880, a brass band played "O Canada" at a banquet in Quebec City held for the governor general, the Marquess of Lorne. The performance was repeated the next day before an audience of 6000 in the gardens of Spencer Wood. The concert featured six bands and for the first time the words were heard, sung by a full choir.

The practice of crafting patriotic songs for public use grew along with nationalism throughout the 19th century. In Canada, politicians and citizens alike had for some time dreamt of a melody with words that would capture the patriotic ideals of the new nation. Various musical pieces drifted into popular use, but it was clear that songs such as "God Save the King (Queen)" or "The Maple Leaf Forever" (with lines like "Wolfe the dauntless hero came") were never going to be popular among French Canadians.

In 1834 at the founding meeting of the St-Jean Baptiste Society, George-Étienne Cartier passionately sang his own composition "Ô Canada! mon pays! mes amours!" Nonetheless in 1865 Ernest Gagnon would still lament that "Vive la Canadienne," sung to the melody of "À la claire fontaine" would have to do until something better came along.

In June 1880 the St-Jean Baptiste Society declared that it was time to find something better. They wanted a patriotic rallying song for their national festival that year. There was talk of a competition, but the music committee decided to ask the respected young composer Calixa Lavallée to compose an anthem and have it ready for June 24. Gagnon's daughter later claimed that it was her father Ernest who came up with the first line and gave it to Adolphe-Basile Routhier, an accomplished poet, to compose the rest. Others claimed that Routhier wrote the words first and Lavallée the music later. Routhier himself later wrote that Lavallée played him his "grand air" and he (Routhier) wrote the four verses the next night.

As for the composer, the peripatetic Lavallée moved several times to the United States, fought for the Union army in the Civil War, traveled to South America, studied in Paris and died in Boston. His travels continued even after death, as his body was brought to Montreal for reburial in 1933.

"O Canada" remained a French only anthem for some 20 years. It was not performed in English Canada until 1901, when it was played in Toronto for the Duke of Cornwall and York (the future King George V). Various translations followed until that of Stanley Weir, published in 1908. With few changes, this is the version sung today. On June 27, 1980 Parliament passed Bill C-36 making "O Canada" Canada's official national anthem.

James H. Marsh is editor in chief of The Canadian Encyclopedia.

Comments

8:01 AM
09/03/10
Like many, if not most Canadians I really am quite proud of "O Canada" -particularly when it is played at events like the Olympics to indicate that once again a Canadian has excelled.

I am dismayed however at the notion that we can go on and on changing the words at will.

How many changes has "The Star-Spangled Banner" undergone? Do Americans ever have to wonder which version of the song is currently in vogue? For this reason...Americans know the words to their anthem.

One of the reasons TV coverage of events like the Olympics shows Canadians mumbling through the words of our anthem is that at any given moment we are always wondering whether or not we are going to go publicly astray by adding a now-discarded "We stand on guard" or missing out on a French inclusion. Sometimes I am tempted just to hum.

We have to leave it alone! It is not a tweet -it is our National Anthem! Such things are unchangeable!

Jock Williams Yogi 13
Recommend this comment
 

The Wire 5

Most recent articles and blogs in HistoryWire

  1. Blog Post

    Canadian Rap on the Rise

  2. Article

    Tegan and Sara

  3. Article

    Our Pet, Juliette!

  4. Blog Post

    A Preliminary Guide to Vintage Canadian Psych Pop

  5. Blog Post

    Keeping an eye on inflation